Thursday, November 10, 2016

Reading Through History: The Game of Silence by Louise Erdrich (2005)

The Game of Silence is the second book in Louise Erdrich's series which began with The Birchbark House. It is now 1850, and Omakayas and her family have received troubling news: the chimookoman - white people - have started driving Indian tribes away from their homes. While the adults decide how to proceed, the children must play the Game of Silence, where prizes are rewarded to the child who can remain quiet the longest. Once it is decided that a member of the tribe will be sent out to gather more information, life resumes its normal rhythm for Omakayas, though always with the threat of losing her way of life hanging over her head. As she begins to discern how she will contribute to her tribe in adulthood, she also gains a deeper appreciation for the place where her family has always lived and what it will mean for them to lose it.

This sequel is every bit as good as the first book of the series. The writing is impeccable, and the storytelling is appropriate for a middle grade audience - honest about the difficulties the Ojibwe face, but not brutally unhappy. It does not discount the sadness Omakayas faces when she realizes her home may be taken from her, but it also shines the light on little glimmers of hope here and there that keep the reader from despairing of Omakayas's fate altogether.

What stood out the most to me, however, is the only potential flaw in the entire story: the portrayal of Catholic priest, Father Baraga.  The scene that gave me pause is from pages 188 and 189 in the hardcover edition: 

"Mikwam, the only way you can gain everlasting life is through my church," said Father Baraga. 

His eyes were kind, almost pleading, as though he were watching them suffer. He pitied them, she thought with surprise, and it almost made her laugh because they pitied him right back. 

"Everlasting life," he said again, softly. 

"Will my father, my mother, my grandfathers, and my grandmothers be there in this everlasting life?" asked Deydey. 

"Were they baptized?" asked Father Baraga.

"No," said Deydey.

"They they will not," the priest answered in a sad voice. 

"Then of course I can't go," said Deydey. "I want to see them."

Father Baraga only scratched his head, underneath his tiny useless cap, and sighed. There was nothing he could do about this family, nothing. 

This scene bothered me because Father Baraga's words do not align with church teaching. The church teaches - and, as I confirmed with a staff apologist at Catholic Answers, has always taught - that unbaptized people can be saved. I have a hard time believing that Father Baraga (who was a real person, and, who, I also learned from my Catholic Answers contact, has been declared Venerable) would not be familiar with this teaching, or would purposely misrepresent it to Omakayas and her family.  It also didn't sit right with me that Father Baraga is willing to state with certainty that any individual does not have everlasting life, as the church teaches that only God can judge the fate of someone's soul. Since Father Baraga is a historical figure, I can't imagine that Erdrich did not research him heavily before including him in her book, but based on what I know of the teachings of the church and Father Baraga himself, something feels off. It almost seems that this priest is being portrayed in an unfairly negative light (along with his "tiny useless cap") for the sake of giving Omakayas more credibility. I can understand the Ojibwe not wanting to adopt Christianity, but I can't understand a priest making the idea less palatable with false information.

This is such a small piece of the book that I don't want to suggest that it spoils the book in any way. As a Catholic parent, it just makes me want to be sure that I read this part of the book with my children to help them accurately understand what the Church teaches so they don't walk away from this book with an unfair misconception of their own faith. I still recommend the book, especially for the upper elementary range, but I will be curious to see how Father Baraga's role evolves (or doesn't) in future books of the series. 

Tuesday, November 8, 2016

Library Haul: Picture Books About Construction and Thanksgiving

We have cards in several library systems, and we often have books checked out from multiple systems at once. This past week, our playgroup met in one of the local libraries, so while we were there, we returned a few titles we were done with, and checked out some new ones. I'm still working my way through the haul I posted a couple of weeks ago, so I didn't borrow anything for myself, just a few picture books.

Most of the books I borrowed were for the second session of my story time, which is coming up tomorrow. I decided I wanted to do a construction theme, and I wasn't sure exactly what I wanted to read, so I borrowed a few familiar titles (plus Bulldozer's Big Day, which is new to me), knowing I could test them out on Miss Muffet before making my final plan.

  • Building a House by Byron Barton
I'm probably not going to read this at story time because it's not really a story, and I think it's too short, but for Miss Muffet, who has been observing new construction on our stroller walks, it will be a perfect way to introduce the vocabulary she needs to talk about what she sees.

  • I Am a Backhoe by Anna Grossnickle Hines
  • Bulldozer's Big Day by Candace Fleming
  • Goodnight, Goodnight, Construction Site by Sherri Duskey Rinker
These are the likeliest story time titles of the bunch, though only Bulldozer's Big Day is really a story with a plot. The others I have used before in story times in the past, but I have to spend some more time with them to figure out the best way to make them engaging. 


  • Roadwork by Sally Sutton
  • Demolition by Sally Sutton
I borrowed these because I knew they were decent rhyming texts with a lot of onompatopoeia. Miss Muffet has heard Roadwork already, and she did enjoyed learning the names of some of the vehicles she has seen around town. Demolition, about knocking down a building, should also appeal to her, since a building not too far from us was demolished recently.

  • Wait! Wait! by Hatsue Nakawaki
While I was browsing the shelves for construction books, I noticed Wait! Wait! on a display, and remembered how much Miss Muffet enjoyed it when she was one. I figured Bo Peep would enjoy it now that she is at that age, and really into pictures of babies, so I added it to our stack.

  • My First Thanksgiving by Tomie de Paola 
  • Over The River And Through The Wood by Lydia Maria Francis Child 
  • Thanksgiving Day by Gail Gibbons
It can be difficult to get our hands on holiday-themed books in our local libraries, so when I noticed that the Thanksgiving shelf was still pretty full, I snagged a few titles just in case we didn't have enough. Miss Muffet is finally old enough for Gail Gibbons's somewhat wordier texts, so her Thanksgiving book was the first one I grabbed, and then I figured a board book would be useful for Bo Peep. (It's not Bo Peep's first Thanksgiving, but that's fine because the book is not really about a baby's first Thanksgiving.) I was originally considering Over the River and Through the Wood for story time, but it's not really formatted well for that, so we'll probably just sing it at home.

Link up your library haul with Sweeping Up Joy!  

Saturday, November 5, 2016

Book Review: Something Wicked This Way Comes by Ray Bradbury (1962)

This week has been Witch Week at Emerald City Book Review. Since I don't read much fantasy, I haven't been able to participate very much, but I have been looking forward to today. This is the day when Witch Week participants are discussing Something Wicked This Way Comes by Ray Bradbury.

The story follows two adolescent boys, Will Halloway and Jack Nightshade, as they repeatedly visit a dark carnival which has come to their town to tempt patrons with the promise of being able to age more slowly or more quickly using a carousel with the power to add or remove years from an individual's life. Looking out for the boys' safety is Will's father, Charles Halloway, who is the janitor at the local library and who has some regrets of his own about the path his life has taken. As these three characters look for ways to defeat the carnivals' evil owners and move back toward the light, they reflect heavily on their pasts and futures, and the states of their own souls.

This is a book I have wanted to read for a long time after loving Dandelion Wine as a teen, and it did not disappoint at all. What Dandelion Wine is for the season of summer, Something Wicked This Way Comes is for the season of fall.  Where Dandelion Wine is bright and warm and full of light and joy and dreams, Something Wicked is dark and cold and full of uncertainty and fear and nightmares. Despite the darkness, however, this is a beautifully written book. I am the kind of reader who drools over well-written description, and this book is filled with passages that are practically poetry. Bradbury clearly loved the English language, and he absolutely lavished this story with well-chosen words and carefully constructed sentences. I started to write down some of my favorite quotations as I read, but quickly realized that to save every word I loved, I'd probably have to copy the entire story.

What spoke to me the most, though, was the way Bradbury describes the powerful grip sin can have over a human being, even one with good intentions who wishes to avoid evil. I think the last time I read a book with such a strong understanding of sin and guilt and temptation it was The Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man by James Joyce. Bradbury, thankfully, is more accessible, and though he does use a lot of words to convey his points, he also has moments where the truth is distilled to a single quotable line.

One such moment is where he writes, "You work twice as hard to be a farmer as to be his hog." This comes in a segment of the story where Charles considers how difficult is can be to always be good, to never give in to temptations.  Though there is more to the passage, this line gets to the heart of the matter, reminding us that we want to be farmers even when it feels like being the hog would be easier to achieve.

Another wonderfully straightforward line that jumped out at me is “Good to evil seems evil.” This is a simple concept, but one that I think human beings neglect to realize. There are many people in the world who do things on a daily basis that are morally wrong, and I know I'm not alone in wondering how they can commit those acts and bring such ugliness into the world. To realize that maybe those actions no longer seem wrong to those individuals gave me such a sense of clarity, even if it was accompanied by a deeper sadness about the fallen state of our world.

This is the best book I have read in a long time, and it's the kind of story that will ruin me for other books for a while until I have a little bit of distance from it. I really want to re-read Dandelion Wine now, and then finish the series, which also includes Farewell, Summer (which I own but have never read) and Summer Morning, Summer Night (the existence of which I didn't even know about until I looked up Something Wicked on Goodreads.)

Friday, November 4, 2016

7 Quick Takes: How We Halloween

At just a few weeks shy of turning three, Miss Muffet is at an age now where she will start to remember from year to year how we celebrate certain holidays and occasions. Therefore, this is the first year where we have had any sort of intentional Halloween celebration in our house. Though we decided not to venture out for trick-or-treat (nor did we bother with any of the many local trunk-or-treats), Miss Muffet and Little Bo Peep both had their fill of Halloween fun, as well as opportunities to celebrate All Saints Day and All Souls Day.

Books

Our go-to method for celebrating any holiday is always to read about it, and we have been reading Halloween-themed books for weeks. We checked out some nonfiction from the library, delved into my own childhood stash, and even listened to the audiobook of Big Pumpkin on YouTube. Reading about Halloween really helped Miss Muffet develop the vocabulary needed to talk about things like costumes, decorations, masks, and being scared, and she really didn't express much anxiety about Halloween at all. She's a little creeped out by skeletons, and did not want to watch the Silly Symphony Skeleton Dance, but overall I think the books helped make her comfortable with the idea that Halloween is mostly just pretend. We also received a small coloring book from her grandmother that came with stickers, which was a big hit.

Attire

Grandma sent outfits for both girls which had black cats on them. They wore them during the day, and then at night, we dressed Miss Muffet up in a costume made entirely from things we had around the house. She wanted to be a pirate, so we dressed her all in black, then tied and draped play silks of various colors over her shoulders, around her waist, and around her head. Then we put some beads on her neck and wrist. My husband made an eye patch from felt and twine, and gave her some sort of tool to hold that vaguely resembled a sword. She didn't wear it for long, but we did take photos for posterity, and I was pretty impressed with the end result.

Scavenger Hunt

During the day, while Daddy was at work, I took the girls outside in the stroller and had Miss Muffet do a scavenger hunt for various Halloween decorations. Our scavenger hunts tend to be pretty basic. I draw poorly planned pictures of the objects we're looking for, hand her a crayon, and she checks them off when we see them. On our list for our Halloween hunt were: a small pumpkin, a big pumpkin, a witch, a skeleton, a ghost, a jack-o-lantern, a spiderweb and a bat. We didn't find any bat decorations, but everything else got a check mark.

Cookie Decorating

Instead of trick-or-treating, which I think is pretty much pointless given that we have a revolving door of new neighbors and never get too know any of them, we baked sugar cookies in Halloween shapes and decorated them with frosting and sprinkles. Miss Muffet, who is a cookie fiend, was thrilled with this project and she helped decorate most of them. 

Ghost Candles

I went to a Party Lite party something like ten years ago and bought a set of ghost candle holders. I pulled those out and we stuck some new tea lights inside and lit them for atmosphere while we ate our cookies. Shortly after, we put out the candles and put Miss Muffet to bed. As I said goodnight to her, she said, "Mama, that was such a great Halloween." Mission accomplished.

One Hundred Saints

On Tuesday morning, in celebration of All Saints Day, I brought out our copy of One Hundred Saints, and just paged through it with Miss Muffet. (Bo Peep looked on from the playpen. She is not allowed near books we want to keep intact.) She was fascinated by St. Denis and wanted to know what happened to his head (I forgot he was in there) and she asked a lot of questions about St. George's horse in the image where he is shown slaying the dragon. ("Is his horse okay? Are you sure?") We made it about three-quarters of the way through the book, which was pretty impressive.

All Souls Family Tree

Finally, for All Souls Day, we talked about Miss Muffet's deceased grandfather, great-grandparents, and great-great grandparents (all of whom died before she was born) and made a little family tree showing their connections to Miss Muffet. Then I said the Prayer for the Poor Souls in Purgatory, and prompted Miss Muffet to say Amen. This was a pretty last-minute activity, but I think I want to repeat it in future years.

As always, 7 Quick Takes is hosted by This Ain't the Lyceum.


Thursday, November 3, 2016

Reading Through History: Calico Bush by Rachel Field (1931)

Calico Bush is the story of Marguerite, a French immigrant to the United States who is orphaned soon after her arrival. With no family to look after her, she becomes a bound out girl, contracted to the Sargent family for six years. As the Sargents work to settle their homestead in the Maine wilderness, under threat of violence from local American Indians, Marguerite, called Maggie, does her best to blend into the family and be of use to them, while also trying to remain true to her heritage.

I had a very frustrating time reading this book. My husband loved it and insisted that I read it, but I kept pausing every 30 pages or so and asking when something was going to happen. Lots of things almost happen, but then the author backs away from them, which made me feel like I was being strung along but never rewarded. When something finally does happen, it's a terrible tragedy involving a young baby that is so unspeakably sad, it feels like a punishment. I had a really hard time connecting with Marguerite, and I also found it difficult to keep track of who was who among the other characters. Only Aunt Hepsa, the wise, elderly neighbor who takes a special liking to Maggie stands out, and that is really only because of her quirkiness.

This book reminded a lot of The Witch of Blackbird Pond, which I also didn't enjoy that much, so this may just be a matter of personal preference regarding stories set in colonial New England. I can't say there was anything wrong with the writing, or the storytelling, or even the characterizations. This book just did not click with me, no matter how hard I tried.

Tuesday, November 1, 2016

Recommended Reading for Catholic Book Clubs

This week's Top Ten Tuesday challenge is to suggest titles for a book club based on its interests in a specific book, subject, author, etc. In keeping with the focus of this blog, I've decided to share fictional books I think would be great for a Catholic book club. Though some of the books mentioned are written by Catholic authors, and have specifically Catholic references, there are also plenty of books by non-Catholics mentioned here. These are books which espouse a Christian worldview consistent with the Church's teachings about sin and redemption, love and sacrifice, belief and faith. (Links throughout the body of this post will take you to my reviews.)

The first two authors I want to mention are so obvious, I almost feel silly including them, but I'd feel just as strange leaving them out. They are, of course, J.R.R. Tolkien and C.S. Lewis. While plenty of non-Catholics enjoy these writers (and C.S. Lewis himself was not Catholic), there is something about Middle Earth and Narnia that is especially appealing to the Catholic mind. I am not a big fantasy reader, as a rule, and I think that is partly because I have a hard time connecting fantasy worlds to my real life. I have not had this problem with The Hobbit or the Lord of the Rings trilogy, or with any of the Narnia books I have read so far. They are not true to my life, but they are true to my faith, and I believe reading these books has bolstered my beliefs in a way that purely secular books simply do not.

Also in the fantasy realm are George MacDonald, author of The Princess and the Goblin and Elizabeth Goudge, author of The Little White Horse. I found the religious references were a little harder to pinpoint in The Princess and the Goblin, though a Christian sensibility pervades the entire text. Little White Horse is not a Catholic book per se, but it talks a lot about repentance and making things right with God, and again, there is a feeling of religiousness about the book which comes across even without explicit statements about a specific faith.

Next is Flannery O'Connor. I first discovered her work in high school, when "Good Country People" was assigned to me in my senior year English elective, "Short Stories." I was blown away by how darkly comical the ending of that story is, and I was pleased to have an author with such a sharp wit on "my" team. Years later, when it came time to write my English thesis, I discovered that certain academics were arguing for a reading of O'Connor that ignores the religious interpretations of her work. Knowing that O'Connor always intended her stories to be of a religious nature, I used my thesis as an opportunity to trace those threads through her novel, Wise Blood, as well as many of her short stories. If you can't get into her stories, try her letters, collected in The Habit of Being. I found that I loved her writing that much more once I got to know her a little bit better.

Another wonderful author, whose books I only discovered last year, is Meriol Trevor. Like O'Connor, she writes explicitly religious novels, generally about conversion from Protestantism to Catholicism. Trevor is British, so her style is quite different from O'Connor's, but her novel, The Rose Round, is the closest thing to a perfect book that I have ever read. (My review explains why.) A close second is Trevor's Sun Slower, Sun Faster, which involves time travel to various points in the history of the Catholic church in England. It also includes the following beautiful passage about the Eucharist:

Then a movement began among the people. They creaked to their feet, shuffled and fumbled up to the front, kneeling on the floor, and she saw little Thomas at the beginning of the row. The priest turned and made the sign of the cross and all signed themselves; then he came forward and moved along the line, placing the Hosts in the mouths of the people. 

Cecil had a very strange feeling; she felt that this was at the same time the most natural and the most unnatural thing she had ever seen. They were like little birds being fed by their mother, and yet it was grown people who knelt to receive what looked like a paper penny of bread on their tongues. She knew at once why the Mass provoked such love and such hate. Either what they believe is true, or else it is a dreadful delusion, she thought.

These two books are written for teens, but they had great significance for me as an adult as well. Trevor's adult novel, Shadows and Images, which is about a fictional woman's friendship with the real John Henry Cardinal Newman, is also a compelling read that I really enjoyed.

Finally, there are two Newbery-winning books that are must-reads for Catholic kids and adults alike: I Juan de Pareja by Elizabeth Borton de Trevino and The Bronze Bow by Elizabeth George Speare.  In  I, Juan de Pareja, title character Juan is a devout Catholic who seeks out the sacrament of Reconciliation after committing an act of wrongdoing. This is a matter-of-fact part of the story, and the sacrament is given its due respect and reverence. The book as a whole is also beautifully written and unexpectedly brought me to tears. The Bronze Bow is set during the time of Jesus and it explores the social and political climate in which Jesus lived and follows a blacksmith's slave on his journey toward Christian belief. Though these books are intended for children, neither is a childish book, and both have much to offer teen and adult readers as well.

Friday, October 28, 2016

7 Quick Takes: The Quotable Little Miss Muffet

Little Miss Muffet, who is almost three, has a sassy personality and precocious vocabulary to match. I share a lot of her profound, bizarre, or just plain funny statements on Facebook, and I also save them all in a Google Document. Here are some of the highlights from the past month or so.


On Her Behavior


Sometimes I make a special day a long day by being naughty.

This kind of serious self-reflection is unusual for her, but no one can argue that she isn't right. We've had some very long days lately.


On How Babies Are Made


Get a baby, mush her up, and put her in a mama.

This was after I explained how apple seeds grow more apples and pumpkin seeds grow more pumpkins. She is very concerned lately about babies growing inside of mommies, despite the fact that we are not currently growing a baby. The other day, she shoved a baby doll up her shirt, then pulled it out and said, "He's being born head first." 


On Her Baby Sister


I love you, little sister, my dear little blue eyes.

She is generally sweet to Little Bo Peep, and I think "my dear little blue eyes" is an adorable nickname. 


Upon Hearing the Bells Ring During the Consecration at Mass


Time to get up!

This was, of course, the Mass in the extraordinary form, and she was the only person making any noise at all at this moment. Later, Bo Peep, also made an impression when she saw another blonde-haired blue-eyed baby and suddenly flung herself across my lap screaming, "Babyyyyyyyy!" I think she thought it was her reflection. 


On Being Left Home While I Teach CCD


When I grow up to be a Mama, I will teach the big kids. At night. And I will leave my baby alone.

She doesn't actually seem to mind when I leave to teach on Monday nights, nor is she left anything even close to alone, but I can see she has big plans for her future. She often talks about what she will do when she is a Mama, and it typically involves typing on computers and writing with pens.


On Belief...


Mama! All Saints Day is coming!

This is only funny because she shouted it out while we were walking with the stroller after several moments of silence. Later the same day, she also randomly called out, "John the 23rd! John Paul the 2nd!" while eating her lunch.


...And Unbelief

Santa Claus is not real, Mama.

I had to be told at age 10 that Santa does not exist, so naturally I have no idea how she arrived at this conclusion. When I expressed my unwavering belief in Santa, however, she just looked at me like I was a complete idiot. I predicted she would be hard to sell on this idea. I just hope she doesn't ruin it for her sister as the years go by.

For more Quick Takes, check out the link-up at This Ain't the Lyceum.